Duaer

Guides

Insurance Claims Automation 2027: Which Claims to Automate First

Adapted from the Duaer documentation site, this article explains how insurers can use value and difficulty scoring to choose the right claim type for a first rollout and set clear pilot boundaries.

Where the Problem Starts

Most insurers do not lack ideas about claims automation. The hard part is deciding which type of claim to automate first. A typical claims department handles a wide range of cases: a cracked windscreen, a kitchen flood, a multi-vehicle accident with disputed liability, and a bodily injury claim that has been open for eighteen months. When a team sets a broad goal like 'automate claims,' the first pilot often picks the hardest cases, because their cost is the most visible. The model looks impressive in a demo, then stalls as soon as it meets a file with no police report, contradictory statements, and a solicitor's letter attached.

The real problem is rarely the technology. It is the selection criteria. Teams often choose a claim type because it is expensive, or because a senior executive mentioned it in a meeting, rather than because it is repetitive, well documented, and low in regulatory risk. By 2027, the insurers that actually capture value from claims automation will treat scope selection as the first and most important decision.

Why Choosing a Claim Type Is Harder Than It Looks

Claims are not one workflow. They are a set of workflows, each with different inputs, decision authority, and room for error. Logging a first notice of loss that only needs a policy number, a date, a location, and a short description is structured work. Deciding whether an ambiguous exclusion applies is judgment work, and every sentence in the letter may carry legal consequences.

The difference matters because automation performs best where inputs are consistent and the decision space is narrow. A system that only needs to read a garage invoice and check it against a labour rate table is far more reliable than one asked to weigh a claimant's medical history against a policy wording written in 2009. If a team mixes these two kinds of work in one pilot, failures on the difficult cases contaminate the team's view of the simple ones, and the project quietly gets shelved.

The second challenge is that claims data is rarely clean. Photos are taken on a phone in poor light. Adjuster notes are free text, full of abbreviations that only the local team understands. Policy documents exist in several versions across different products. Before evaluating any model, answer a basic question: for at least most cases, can the data needed for the decision be found reliably? If the answer is no, that claim type is not ready, no matter how attractive the savings figure in a spreadsheet looks.

Common Mistakes When Choosing the First Claim Type

The most common mistake is starting with the largest claims. High-value claims deserve executive attention, but they usually come with litigation risk, need experienced loss adjusters, and take a long time to resolve. The savings are also hard to measure, because outcomes depend on negotiation and not just processing speed. A pilot in this area can take a year and still produce an evaluation nobody trusts.

The second mistake is letting the system make decisions before the preparation work is automated. Many teams want automatic approval or automatic denial from day one. In practice, the earliest value often comes from preparation: gathering documents, extracting fields from forms, checking whether the policy was in force on the date of loss, and routing the case to the right queue. These tasks save adjusters time without requiring the system to determine liability.

The third mistake is ignoring what adjusters think of the work. Adjusters know which files tend to come back for rework. If a pilot is designed without their input, the team may automate a step that was never the bottleneck. One team spent three months building a tool to review estimates, only to find that the real delay was waiting for the claimant to send a second photo.

How to Rank Claim Types by Value and Difficulty

A practical approach is to score each candidate claim type on two dimensions. The first is value, which includes monthly case volume, average handling time, rework rate, and the cost of delayed customer communication. The second is difficulty, which includes input consistency, the number of documents required, the amount of human judgment involved, regulatory sensitivity of the decision, and how often outcomes are disputed.

Place the candidate types on a simple grid. Claims with high volume, high consistency, and low regulatory sensitivity sit in the upper left and are natural starting points. Claims with low volume, heavy judgment, and frequent disputes sit in the lower right and should wait. The middle ground is usually where most organisations find their first real pilot, often in claim types with a clear and repeatable document set.

The scoring has to be honest. Ask the head of claims operations to verify volume and handling-time data from the operational systems, rather than estimating from memory. Ask legal and compliance to mark which decisions must keep a written human rationale under local rules. Two weeks spent scoring with real data is worth far more than a decision made quickly in a steering committee meeting.

Choosing the First Pilot with Clear Boundaries

Once the shortlist is set, the first pilot needs a boundary that the team can state in one sentence. For example: 'For single-vehicle glass claims below a set value limit, extract and validate the data in the repair estimate; route any file that fails validation to a human adjuster.' That sentence defines the input, the task, the threshold, and the fallback. Each part can be tested on its own.

A good pilot also states what the system will not do. It will not deny claims, it will not determine liability, and it will not contact claimants without human review. A clear list of exclusions prevents scope creep and shortens the risk discussion with compliance considerably.

Measure from day one. Track the share of files that pass without manual correction, the average time from first notice of loss to first decision, the rate at which adjusters overturn the system's output, and the number of follow-up contacts from customers. These metrics show whether the pilot is genuinely improving the work or just moving the work into a different queue. Do not report only the most visible time saving, because it can hide error costs that only appear weeks later.

Finally, plan for handover. A pilot that works in one adjuster team often fails when moved to another region where the documents and thresholds differ. Record the conditions under which the scenario was validated, so that the next rollout starts from evidence rather than assumptions.

People and Data Foundations, and Actions for This Week

Claims automation is a change to operating models as much as a technology change. Adjusters need to understand what the system does, how to overturn its output, and how their feedback changes it. Without this understanding, they either ignore the output or accept it without checking, and both outcomes are risky. Set up a short review routine in which adjusters flag errors each week and can see what improvements their feedback led to.

Check data readiness separately before the pilot starts. Confirm that the fields the system needs actually exist in the source systems, that updates are consistent, and that access rights are properly controlled. Sensitive claimant information must be handled in line with your data protection obligations. Any data that leaves its established boundary should be reviewed with compliance before the pilot launches.

A practical step for this week: put your current claim list into a one-page table with five columns: claim type, monthly volume, average handling time, share of files that need rework, and regulatory sensitivity. Pull the figures from the claims system rather than estimating them. Then highlight the two claim types with the highest volume and lowest sensitivity, and write one sentence for each describing the pilot boundary. Take this table to the head of claims operations and ask one question: of these two, which would you trust the system to prepare materials for, but not to decide?

If you want to turn this scoping work into a repeatable workflow, you can set up intake, document checks, and review queues directly in Duaer at https://www.duaer.com . We suggest registering first, testing on a single claim type, and only then deciding whether to expand. We recommend this tool because it keeps boundaries, audit trails, and human fallback visible at all times, which is easier to govern than an ad hoc pilot.

If you would like to describe your own scenario, we can provide a written rollout path. Submission link: https://api.duaer.com/form/c59a907a-3697-4edf-a04d-3ea0fb72fdc8

Questions

Which type of insurance claim should insurers automate first?

Insurers usually should start with claim types that have high volume, consistent inputs, low regulatory sensitivity, and a clear set of documents, such as glass claims or smaller claims where repair estimates are standardised. Large, litigated, or judgment-heavy claims are generally better left for later.

How should an insurance claims automation pilot be measured?

Besides average handling time, track the share of files that pass without manual correction, the rate at which adjusters overturn system output, and the number of follow-up customer contacts. Measuring time savings alone can miss the hidden costs of rework and errors.

Should claims automation start with automatic claim denial?

No. A safer approach is to begin with preparation work such as document collection, field extraction, policy validity checks, and case routing. This saves adjuster time while keeping liability and denial decisions with humans, and expands only after the data and processes have been validated.